Top 8 Propane Pool Heaters for Ultimate Comfort

Ted Curley
Journeymen wiremen at US Electric-International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers (IBEW)

Hello, I'm Ted Curley, a licensed electrician with a wealth of experience in the electrical field. I've launched this platform to share my extensive knowledge and insights with you. My journey in the electrical field spans over a decade, during which I have cultivated a deep understanding and expertise in...Read more

Ted Curley
Journeymen wiremen at US Electric-International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers (IBEW)

Hello, I'm Ted Curley, a licensed electrician with a wealth of experience in the electrical field. I've launched this platform to share my extensive knowledge and insights with you. My journey in the electrical field spans over a decade, during which I have cultivated a deep understanding and expertise in...Read more

Hello there! In this post, I'm excited to share with you the top 8 propane pool heaters that will bring you the ultimate comfort while swimming in your pool. Whether you're looking to extend your swimming season or simply want to enjoy a warm and cozy pool experience, these heaters are sure to meet your needs. So, let's dive in and explore the best options out there!

1
Raypak Avia Propane Gas Pool Heater
✯ Summary: Convenient ✯
BUY NOW Amazon.com
9.4
2
Hayward W3H400FDP Propane Pool Heater
Final Verdict: Reliable and Efficient
BUY NOW Amazon.com
7.5
3
Raypak Polymer Headers Propane Heater
7.6
4
Hayward H-Series Pool Heater, Beige
In conclusion
BUY NOW Amazon.com
7.3
5
Raypak 406K Propane Pool Heater
6.6
6
Pentair EC-462025 White Heaters
6.4
7
Raypak 150K BTU Propane Gas Pool Heater
6.2
8
Raypak Propane Pool and Spa Heater
6
1

Raypak Avia Propane Gas Pool Heater

 in stock
Amazon.com
8.4
Summary: Convenient
The Raypak Avia P-R404A-EP-C Propane Gas Pool Heater is a convenient and efficient option for pool heating, offering integrated Wi-Fi for remote control and real-time service alerts, as well as easy temperature control through the Raymote Temperature and Heater Control App. It also comes with self-protection features for added safety. However, it is important to note that this product has limited availability and is priced higher compared to similar models.
Efficient and Reliable
  • Convenient remote control and real-time service alerts through integrated Wi-Fi
  • Easy temperature control on-the-go with the Raymote Temperature and Heater Control App
  • Provides self-protection features for added safety
  • Utilizes propane gas for efficient heating of the pool
Limitations
  • Limited availability
  • Higher price compared to similar models

The Raypak Avia P-R404A-EP-C Propane Gas Pool Heater 018039 is a game-changer when it comes to pool heating. With its advanced Wi-Fi enabled control system, you have the power to control your pool heater settings from anywhere using your phone. Adjust the water temperature or check on other pool functions with ease, thanks to the Raymote remote Wi-Fi connection. This heater also offers real-time updates, allowing you to stay informed of any service or maintenance needs. With smarter controls and an easy-to-use touch control interface, managing your pool heater has never been simpler. Plus, its self-protection features ensure peace of mind. With dimensions of 53 x 39 x 38 inches and weighing 135 pounds, this Raypak heater is a reliable and efficient choice for any pool or spa.

Efficient and Reliable Pool Heating
  • Integrated Wi-Fi for real-time service alerts and remote control
  • Raymote Temperature and Heater Control App for on-the-go control of pool temperature
  • Self-protection features
  • Propane gas pool heater
2

Hayward W3H400FDP Propane Pool Heater

$67.11  in stock
Amazon.com
as of May 19, 2024 1:26 am
7.8
Final Verdict: Reliable and Efficient
The Hayward W3H400FDP Universal H-Series 400,000 BTU Propane Pool and Spa Heater is a powerful and efficient option for in-ground pools and spas. With easy installation and good temperature control, it offers premium performance. However, occasional unexplained shutdowns and the need to purchase a pressure relief valve separately are minor drawbacks to consider.
Pros
  • Powerful heating capability
  • Suitable for in-ground pools and spas
  • Easy installation process
  • Good temperature control
  • Durable construction
Cons of Hayward W3H400FDP
  • Occasional shutdown without explanation
  • Pressure relief valve not included, which can lead to permanent damage if not purchased separately

The Hayward W3H400FDP Universal H-Series 400,000 BTU Propane Pool and Spa Heater is an excellent choice for in-ground pools and spas up to 1,200 ft². With its durable cupro nickel heat exchanger, it provides exceptional protection against corrosion and premature failure, ensuring long-lasting performance. This heater offers industry-leading hydraulic performance and lightning-fast speed-to-heat capability, so you can spend more time enjoying your pool and less time waiting for it to warm up. Plus, its low NOx emissions make it environmentally friendly and compliant with air quality standards.

Efficient and Powerful Pool Heating
$67.11
in stock
as of May 19, 2024 1:26 am
Amazon.com
3

Raypak Polymer Headers Propane Heater

 in stock
Amazon.com
7.6
The Raypak 014786 Polymer Headers Digital Control/Electronic Ignition/Propane P-R156A-EP-C Heater offers great features like polymer headers, digital control, electronic ignition, and a propane fuel option. However, there have been concerns regarding potential heat exchanger cracking and difficulties with warranty claims.
Efficient and Durable
  • Polymer Headers
  • Digital Control
  • Electronic Ignition
  • Propane fuel option
Limitations
  • Potential for heat exchanger cracking
  • Difficulties with warranty claims

The Raypak 014786 Polymer Headers Digital Control/Electronic Ignition/Propane P-R156A-EP-C Heater is the perfect choice for larger above-ground pools, spas, and in-ground pools. With up to 50% more BTUs than its competitors, this heater ensures a quicker heat-up, allowing you to extend your swim season and enjoy your pool earlier and later in the year. Equipped with polymer headers, a digital thermostat, and automatic water bypass, this heater provides efficient and convenient control over your pool's temperature. However, it's important to note that some customers have reported issues with the heat exchanger cracking, leading to warranty concerns. It's always good to research and consider different options before making a purchase.

Efficient and Durable Heating Solution
  • Polymer Headers
  • Digital Control
  • Electronic Ignition
  • Propane fuel option
  • Automatic water bypass
  • Digital Thermostat
4

Hayward H-Series Pool Heater, Beige

$64.00  in stock
Amazon.com
as of May 19, 2024 1:26 am
7.3
In conclusion
The Hayward W3H135FDP H-Series Pool Heater in Beige is a reliable and high-performing pool heater with a durable cupro nickel heat exchanger and an intuitive electronic panel. However, it would be helpful if the product description clearly stated whether it is for propane or natural gas, and some users may have difficulty finding a propane to gas conversion kit.
Benefits of Hayward H-Series Pool Heater
  • Durable cupro nickel heat exchanger
  • Industry-leading hydraulic performance
  • Intuitive and easy-to-operate electronic panel
Potential Concerns
  • Description does not clearly specify whether it is propane or natural gas
  • Difficulties in finding a propane to gas conversion kit

The Hayward W3H135FDP H-Series Pool Heater in Beige is a reliable and efficient heating solution for your pool. With its durable cupro nickel heat exchanger, it provides industry-leading hydraulic performance and faster speed-to-heat capability. The intuitive and easy-to-operate electronic panel makes it a breeze to control and adjust the temperature. Plus, its exclusive “Totally Managed” cupro nickel heat exchanger water flow ensures optimal performance. With low NOx emissions, this pool heater meets environmental standards. It's a great choice for keeping your pool at the perfect temperature all season long.

Efficient and Stylish Heating Solution
  • Durable cupro nickel heat exchanger
  • Industry-leading hydraulic performance
  • Intuitive and easy-to-operate electronic panel
  • Exclusive “Totally Managed” cupro nickel heat exchanger water flow
  • Low NOx emissions
$64.00
in stock
as of May 19, 2024 1:26 am
Amazon.com
5

Raypak 406K Propane Pool Heater

 in stock
Amazon.com
6.6
In summary
The Raypak 406,000 BTU Digital Electronic Ignition Propane Pool Heater offers great heating performance with easy installation and surprisingly quiet operation. However, it does not include the required draft hood stack and some users have reported difficulties with lighting the heater.
Heating Efficiency
  • Great heating performance
  • Easy installation
  • Surprisingly quiet operation
Limitations
  • Required draft hood stack not included
  • Issues lighting the heater

The Raypak 406,000 BTU Digital Electronic Ignition Propane Pool Heater is a durable and efficient choice for heating your pool or spa. With its unique “pagoda design,” this heater can withstand high wind speeds and downdrafts, ensuring its effectiveness even in challenging weather conditions. The cabinet of the heater is made from galvanized metal and powder coated with a 7-stage process, making it resistant to elements and corrosion. Inside, the heater features polymer resin headers and a copper fin tube heat exchanger, which quickly and efficiently heats the water passing through. Setting your desired temperature is a breeze with the built-in Microprocessor Controlled Thermostat, and the heater also comes with remote compatibility for added convenience. With its built-in diagnostic controls and electronic ignition, this heater is not only easy to use but also helps conserve gas usage. Whether you have a pool or spa, this heater is an excellent choice for reliable and efficient heating.

Efficient and Powerful Heating Solution
6

Pentair EC-462025 White Heaters

 in stock
Amazon.com
6.4
Based on the information, the Pentair EC-462025 Heaters, White is a compact and efficient option for heating smaller bodies of water up to 15,000 gallons. However, some customers have experienced issues such as control board failure and receiving damaged units.
Efficient Heating Solution
  • 125,000 BTUs
  • Designed for smaller bodies of water up to 15,000 gallons
  • Compact design
Drawbacks
  • Control board failure after 2 days
  • Heater arrived damaged and unusable

The Pentair EC-462025 Heaters in white are designed for smaller pools, with a propane heater boasting 125,000 BTUs. It is compact and efficient, with an 82-percent efficiency compared to larger pool heaters. The quiet operation ensures that it won't disturb your leisure pool time. However, based on the reviews, there have been some unfortunate experiences with this product. One customer received a damaged heater with broken inner parts, rendering it useless. Another customer had a control board failure after just two days of use and faced difficulties with warranty coverage and customer service. Additionally, a customer mentioned issues with warranty support from Pentair for units purchased through Amazon. Overall, while the product has its features, it's essential to be aware of these potential challenges.

Efficient and Reliable Heating Solution
  • 125,000 BTUs
  • Designed for smaller bodies of water up to 15,000 gallons
  • Compact design
  • 82-percent efficiency
  • Quiet operation
7

Raypak 150K BTU Propane Gas Pool Heater

 in stock
Amazon.com
6.2
In summary
The Raypak 014786-156A Propane Gas Pool Heater is a stylish and efficient option for heating your pool, with easy installation and simple controls. While it offers efficient heating at an affordable price, some customers have reported difficulties with customer service and returns, and it may be slightly pricier than other models on the market.
Benefits of the Raypak Pool Heater
  • Easy installation
  • Simple controls
  • Efficient heating
  • Affordable price
Weaknesses
  • Drawbacks:
  • Difficulties with customer service and returns
  • Higher price compared to other models

The Raypak 014786-156A Propane Gas Pool Heater 150K BTU for 0-1999ft Elevation is a reliable and efficient option to heat your above ground pool or spa. With its PolyTuf powder coating and polymer headers, this heater is built to withstand various weather conditions and provide uninterrupted heating performance. The high-quality copper fin tube heat exchanger ensures maximum heat transfer, while the AFT digital control panel and microprocessor-controlled thermostat make it easy to set and maintain your desired temperature. The Raypak 014786-156A also comes with self-diagnostics for easy troubleshooting and can be integrated into your pool control system. Its automatic by-pass control allows for easy flow rate adjustment, and the stainless steel burners and polymer headers ensure durability. Overall, this heater offers both convenience and efficiency for your pool heating needs.

Efficient and Powerful Heating Solution
  • Propane Gas Pool Heater
  • 150K BTU heating capacity
  • Suitable for 0-1999ft Elevation
  • Stylish black color
  • User-friendly design
8

Raypak Propane Pool and Spa Heater

 in stock
Amazon.com
6
In summary
The Raypak 105,000 BTU Swimming Pool and Spa Heater is an efficient and compact option for above ground pools, smaller in-ground pools, and spas. It has a quick temperature increase and an easy installation process. However, there have been reports of leaking issues and a possibility of internal damage during delivery, so caution should be taken.
Efficient Heating Solution
  • Efficient heating capability
  • Quick temperature increase
  • Compact design
Weaknesses
  • Leaking issue reported by one customer
  • Possibility of internal damage due to mishandling during delivery

The Raypak 105,000 BTU Swimming Pool and Spa Heater – Propane is a compact and powerful heating solution for small above-ground pools and spas. With its corrosion Polymer Headers and durable construction, this heater is built to last and provide reliable performance for years to come. Its simple analog thermostat dial allows for easy temperature adjustment, ensuring that your pool or spa is always at your desired temperature. This heater is designed for easy installation and can be powered by either 120V or 240V, making it versatile and convenient. Extend your swim season and enjoy your pool or spa whenever you want with the Raypak 105,000 BTU Swimming Pool and Spa Heater – Propane.

Explore further:  Top 7 Camping Heaters: Stay Warm in the Great Outdoors!
Efficient and Reliable Heating Solution
  • Easy installation on above ground pools, smaller in-ground pools, and spas
  • Standard 120v 3-prong power cord or can be easily converted to 220v
  • Simple analog thermostat dial for accurate pool and spa temperature setting
  • 1/2″ NPT gas connection

Exploring Other Options

Affordable options for keeping your pool comfortably heated

  • Budget-friendly options ($500 – $800): These heaters are usually compact and efficient, designed for smaller pools or spas. They provide reliable heating but may have limited features or lower BTU output
  • Mid-range options ($800 – $1,500): In this price range, you can find pool heaters with a good balance of performance and affordability. They often offer higher BTU output, better energy efficiency, and additional features like digital controls or diagnostic displays
  • Premium options ($1,500 and above): These top-of-the-line propane pool heaters are built to last and provide exceptional heating performance. They are typically energy-efficient, have advanced features like smart controls or remote access, and are suitable for larger pools or commercial applications
  • Variable-speed models: Some propane pool heaters have variable-speed capabilities, allowing you to adjust the heating output to match your specific needs. These models often fall into the mid to premium price range, offering greater flexibility and energy savings
  • Installation and maintenance costs: Keep in mind that the price of a propane pool heater does not include installation and maintenance expenses. Hiring a professional for installation and regular maintenance may incur additional costs, but it ensures proper setup and extends the lifespan of your heater
  • Remember, the specific prices may vary depending on the brand, model, and your location. It's always a good idea to compare features and read customer reviews before making a purchase decision

Getting the most out of your best propane pool heater

  • First, ensure proper installation:
  • Read the manufacturer's instructions carefully to understand the specific requirements for installation
  • Set up the propane pool heater in a well-ventilated area, away from any flammable materials
  • Connect the heater to the propane gas supply using the recommended fittings and hoses
  • Locate the control panel on the propane pool heater
  • Understand the different dials and buttons, such as temperature settings, power switches, and safety features
  • Adjust the temperature to your desired level using the control knob or digital display
  • Before starting the heater, ensure that the pool's water circulation system is functioning properly
  • Open the propane gas valve slowly and check for any gas leaks using a soapy water solution
  • Turn on the propane pool heater using the appropriate power switch or ignition button
  • Monitor the heater during operation and follow any additional safety guidelines provided by the manufacturer
  • Remember, it's always a good idea to consult the instruction manual or seek professional assistance if you have any doubts or concerns about using a propane pool heater. Stay safe and enjoy your warm pool!
Ted CurleyJourneymen wiremen at US Electric-International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers (IBEW)

Hello, I'm Ted Curley, a licensed electrician with a wealth of experience in the electrical field. I've launched this platform to share my extensive knowledge and insights with you. My journey in the electrical field spans over a decade, during which I have cultivated a deep understanding and expertise in various roles. Let me take you through my journey and my passion for electricity and space heaters. If you have any questions, feel free to drop me a line at ted.curley@tedreviews.com

More Posts

3 Comments
Show all Most Helpful Highest Rating Lowest Rating Add your review
  1. Thank you for putting together this roundup! It’s great to have a list of propane pool heaters to choose from. I agree with the author’s choices for the most part, but I would have liked to see more information on the energy efficiency of each heater.

  2. Out of all the options listed, my favorite would have to be the Raypak Avia Propane Gas Pool Heater. I’ve had it for a few months now and it has been fantastic. Not only does it heat up my pool quickly, but it’s also very efficient and easy to use. Highly recommend!

  3. I really like the variety of options in this roundup! However, I wish the pricing and value were discussed more in depth. It would be helpful to know which products offer the best bang for your buck.

Leave a reply

Tedreviews.com
Logo