Discover the Top 7 Water Heater Elements for Hard Water!

Steve Donaldson Master HVAC technician
Steve Donaldson
Master HVAC technician at Quality Comfort Home Services

I am Steve Donaldson, a Master HVAC technician with a rich background in addressing heating issues, especially when it comes to various types of water heaters. Leveraging my extensive expertise, I offer insights and advice to help individuals maintain a warm and secure home environment. Reach out to me at steve.donaldson@tedreviews.com for valuable tips from a seasoned professional in the industry.

Steve Donaldson Master HVAC technician
Steve Donaldson
Master HVAC technician at Quality Comfort Home Services

I am Steve Donaldson, a Master HVAC technician with a rich background in addressing heating issues, especially when it comes to various types of water heaters. Leveraging my extensive expertise, I offer insights and advice to help individuals maintain a warm and secure home environment. Reach out to me at steve.donaldson@tedreviews.com for valuable tips from a seasoned professional in the industry.

Hey there! Are you tired of dealing with hard water issues and the constant damage it can cause to your water heater? Well, worry no more! In this post, I'm going to introduce you to the top 7 water heater elements specifically designed to tackle hard water problems head-on. Say goodbye to those pesky mineral deposits and say hello to a longer-lasting and more efficient water heater. So, let's dive right in and discover the best water heater elements that will make your life easier and your showers more enjoyable!

1

Camco Water Heater Element – 1500W, 120V

$14.99  in stock
Amazon.com
as of April 12, 2024 10:17 am
9.3
Highly recommended!
The Camco 02463 1500W 120V Water Heater Element is a perfect fit for your water heater. It is affordable, easy to install, and provides reliable heating with its low watt density.
Efficient and Reliable
  • Perfect fit
  • Affordable
  • Easy to install

The Camco 02463 1500W 120V Water Heater Element is a reliable and efficient option for areas with problematic water. Its low watt density design helps reduce lime deposit buildup, making it ideal for areas with hard water or lime issues. This screw-in type element is compatible with most models of water heaters manufactured after 1994, including popular brands like American, AO Smith, Bradford White, and more. With its UL listing and easy installation, this replacement element is a perfect fit for your water heater. Customers have praised its performance, noting that it works great and is a cost-effective solution.

Efficient and Reliable Heating Power
  • Low Watt Density heating element
  • 120V/5500W
  • UL Listed
  • Easy to install
  • Minimum tank diameter 10
$14.99
in stock
as of April 12, 2024 10:17 am
Amazon.com
2

Camco 02583 Water Heater Element

$17.49
$15.11
 in stock
Amazon.com
as of April 12, 2024 10:17 am
9.1
Highly recommended
The Camco 02583 4500W 240V Screw-in Foldback Water Heater Element is a highly efficient and durable heating element that is easy to install and compatible with most water heaters. It also helps reduce lime deposit buildup in hard water areas. However, it may have limited compatibility with certain water heaters and some users may need professional installation assistance. Overall, it is a great product for efficient and long-lasting heating.
Efficient and Reliable
  • Easy installation
  • Efficient and long-lasting heating
  • Universally compatible with most water heaters
  • Reduces lime deposit buildup
Drawbacks
  • Limited compatibility with certain water heaters
  • May require a professional installation for some users

The Camco 02583 4500W 240V Screw-in Foldback Water Heater Element is a versatile and reliable solution for replacing your existing water heater element. With its low watt density design, it helps reduce lime deposit buildup in areas with hard water. The element is compatible with a wide range of water heater models from various brands, making it a convenient choice for many households. It is easy to install with its 1-inch NPSM threaded carbon steel bushing and durable rubber gasket. With a 1-year limited warranty and UL listing for both US and Canada, this water heater element is a cost-effective and dependable option to ensure your hot water supply is restored efficiently.

Efficient Heating Solution
  • Screw-in design for easy installation
  • Low watt density for efficient and long-lasting heating
  • Universally compatible with most water heaters
  • Reduces lime deposit buildup in hard water areas
$15.11
$17.49
in stock
as of April 12, 2024 10:17 am
Amazon.com
3

Rheem UV12899 Heating Element, Chrome

$14.59  in stock
Amazon.com
as of April 12, 2024 10:17 am
8.9
The Rheem UV12899 Heating Element is an easy to install and affordable option for your water heater. However, be cautious if you have a 20 amp breaker as it may trip, and there have been reports of some customers receiving a different brand than what was advertised.
Efficient and Reliable
Cons
  • May trip a 20 amp breaker if used with a water heater that has a 20 amp breaker
  • Some customers received a different brand (Preferred) than what was advertised (Rheem)

The Rheem UV12899 Heating Element is a 240V/4500W copper non-resistored HWD element that is 7 5/8 inches long. It is a universal part that can be easily installed with its 1-inch screw-in design. This heating element is designed to provide efficient heating for your water heater. It comes with a rubber ‘O' ring gasket and instructions for easy installation. The product is manufactured by Rheem, although some customers have received the ‘Preferred' brand. Overall, this heating element is recommended by customers and performs as advertised. However, it is important to note that it may cause issues if used with a 20 amp breaker due to its high wattage.

Powerful and Reliable Heating Element
  • 240V/4500W heating element
  • 7 5/8-inch height, width, and depth
  • Universal parts compatibility
  • Model number: UV12899
$14.59
in stock
as of April 12, 2024 10:17 am
Amazon.com
4

DERNORD 240V 4500W Screw-in Water Heater Element

$33.99  in stock
Amazon.com
as of April 12, 2024 10:17 am
8.7
In summary
The DERNORD 240V 4500W Water Heater Element is a powerful and durable heating element that is easy to install and compatible with most American water heaters. Although there are some quality concerns with the wire screws and plastic housing, overall it provides fast and powerful heating for your water. However, it may not be as durable as copper element variants.
Efficient Heating Solution
  • Fast and incident-free shipping
  • High watt density for powerful heating
  • Stainless steel construction for durability
  • Easy installation process
Disadvantages
  • Quality concerns with wire screws and plastic housing
  • Not as durable as copper element variants

The DERNORD 240V 4500W Water Heater Element is a high watt density stainless steel heating element that provides 4500w of power at 240v. Its stainless steel surface is electropolished for durability and corrosion resistance. This water heater element is easy to install and fits most Water Heater Models of American. It is a reliable option for those who have hard water and want a durable and efficient heating element for their water heater. However, there have been some reviews mentioning concerns about the wire screws and the plastic housing, so it's important to take these into consideration when purchasing. Overall, this product offers a fast and efficient solution for heating your water.

Efficient and Powerful Heating Solution
  • High watt density for powerful heating
  • Stainless steel construction for durability
  • Easy installation process
  • Compatible with most American water heater models
5

Eastman 60058 Water Heater Element

$18.39
$11.12
Amazon.com
as of April 12, 2024 10:17 am
8.4
The Eastman 60058 Straight Water Heater Element, with its high watt density and corrosion protection, is an easy-to-install product that works as expected. However, there have been some reported quality issues and not all units perform as expected.
Efficient Heating Solution
  • Easy installation
  • Works as expected
  • High watt density
  • Corrosion protection
Drawbacks
  • Some units may have quality issues
  • Not all units perform as expected

The Eastman 60058 Straight Water Heater Element is a high-quality and reliable product that is designed to provide efficient heating for your water heater. With its high watt density and wattage and voltage of 240V x 4500W, it ensures quick heating of water. The element features a universal flange mount with a gasket and is coated with a copper sheath to protect against corrosion, ensuring its durability. The straight element design makes it suitable for use in most water heaters, and it can be easily installed. Overall, this water heater element is designed to deliver excellent performance and is a popular choice among users.

Please note that the product description provided is based on the information and reviews given, and may not be entirely accurate or complete.

Efficient and Reliable Heating
  • High watt density
  • Wattage and voltage of 240V x 4500W
  • Universal flange mount
  • Gasket coated with a copper sheath
  • Corrosion protection
  • 13 inch minimum measurement
$11.12
$18.39
as of April 12, 2024 10:17 am
Amazon.com
6

Reliance 4,500W Universal Flange Water Heater Element

$15.29
Amazon.com
as of April 12, 2024 10:17 am
8.2
Overall
The Reliance 9000094 4,500 Watt 240 Volt Universal Flange Water Heater Element is a versatile option that is compatible with most water heaters. It offers easy installation with the included square gasket and does not require screws in the flanges. However, be aware that it lacks detailed instructions and may not be compatible with all water heaters.
Efficient and Versatile
Drawbacks
  • No detailed instructions provided
  • Not compatible with all water heaters

The Reliance 9000094 4,500 Watt 240 Volt Universal Flange Water Heater Element is a reliable and affordable solution for your water heating needs. With its 4 hole square flange bracket and included square gasket, it is designed to fit most makes and models that do not use screws in flanges. It has a minimum tank diameter of 14 inches, making it suitable for a wide range of water heaters. Customers have praised its easy installation and its ability to provide very hot water, even in older water heaters. With its excellent price and great service, this water heater element is definitely worth considering. Don't let cold water ruin your day, keep an extra pair on hand and ensure you always have a steady supply of hot water.

Efficient and Versatile Heating Solution
  • Universal flange water heater element
  • Compatible with most makes and models
  • Includes square gasket for easy installation
  • 4 hole square flange bracket design
  • No screws required in flanges
  • Suitable for tanks with a minimum diameter of 14 inches
7

EWH-05 Electric Water Heater Tune-Up Kit

$49.89
Amazon.com
as of April 12, 2024 10:17 am
7.8
In summary
The EWH-05 Electric Water Heater Tune-Up Kit is a comprehensive and affordable option for maintaining and repairing your water heater. It includes all the necessary elements and tools for easy installation, and the provided instructions are helpful. However, some users have reported issues with constant tripping after installation, and there was one instance where a customer had to return the kit because their water heater needed to be replaced entirely due to sediment and corrosion.
Efficient Performance Upgrade
  • Comprehensive kit with all necessary elements and tools included
  • Good instructions provided for easy installation
  • Great value for the price
Weaknesses
  • Some users reported issues with constant tripping after installation
  • One customer had to return the kit because they needed a whole new hot water heater due to sediment and corrosion

The EWH-05 Electric Water Heater Tune-Up Kit is designed to provide a convenient solution for replacing the most common problems in an electric water heater. With this kit, you can easily renew the electrical components of your water heater, prolonging its lifespan. The kit includes two 4,500-watt, 240-volt water heater elements, along with two protective covers, two element gaskets, a quick change tool, and two wrenches. Additionally, it comes with an upper thermostat and a lower thermostat, both of which are adjustable and UL certified. The kit provides everything you need to replace and upgrade your water heater's components, ensuring efficient and reliable heating.

Enhance Your Water Heater!
  • Two 4500W 240V Water Heater Elements
  • Upper Thermostat
  • Lower Thermostat
  • Two Protective Covers
  • Two Elements Gaskets
  • Quick Change Tool
  • Two Wrench

Choosing the Right Water Heater Element for Hard Water

Are there any DIY methods I can use to remove hard water deposits from a water heater element?

Yes, there are a few DIY methods you can try to remove hard water deposits from a water heater element. Here are a couple of options:

  1. Vinegar Soak: You can try soaking the water heater element in white vinegar. Start by disconnecting the power supply to the water heater. Then, remove the element from the tank and place it in a container filled with vinegar. Let it soak for a few hours or overnight. After soaking, use a soft brush or cloth to gently scrub away any remaining deposits. Rinse the element thoroughly and reinstall it in the water heater.
  2. Citric Acid Flush: Another option is to use citric acid to dissolve the hard water deposits. Begin by turning off the power to the water heater. Then, remove the element and place it in a bucket or container. Mix citric acid powder with warm water according to the manufacturer's instructions. Pour the mixture over the element, ensuring it is fully submerged. Let it sit for a couple of hours, occasionally agitating the solution. Afterward, rinse the element thoroughly and reinstall it.
Explore further:  Top 7 Electric Heat Pump Pool Heaters

Are there any specific maintenance or cleaning procedures for water heater elements in hard water areas?

Yes, in hard water areas, it is recommended to follow specific maintenance and cleaning procedures for water heater elements. Hard water contains high levels of minerals, such as calcium and magnesium, which can accumulate on the heating elements over time and reduce their efficiency. Here are some steps you can take to maintain and clean water heater elements in hard water areas:

  1. Regular inspection: Check the condition of the water heater elements periodically. Look for any signs of mineral buildup, such as a white or brownish scale on the surface.
  2. Flushing the system: To remove sediment and mineral deposits, it is advisable to flush the water heater system regularly. Turn off the power supply, close the cold water inlet valve, and attach a garden hose to the drain valve at the bottom of the tank. Open the valve and let the water flow until it runs clear.
  3. Descaling agents: If there is significant mineral buildup on the elements, you can use a descaling agent specifically designed for water heaters. Follow the manufacturer's instructions to safely remove the scale. It's important to note that not all water heater models are compatible with descaling agents, so refer to your unit's manual or consult a professional if unsure.
  4. Anode rod inspection: The anode rod is a sacrificial component that helps prevent corrosion inside the tank. In hard water areas, the anode rod can deteriorate faster due to increased mineral content. Check the anode rod annually and replace it if necessary, following the manufacturer's recommendations.
  5. Water softener installation: Consider installing a water softener if your area has extremely hard water. A water softener will remove minerals from the water supply, reducing the chances of scale buildup on the elements and prolonging the lifespan of your water heater.

Are there specific water heater elements designed to handle hard water?

Yes, there are indeed specific water heater elements designed to handle hard water. These elements are typically made of materials that are resistant to the mineral buildup caused by hard water. They are often coated with a layer of magnesium oxide or other similar substances that prevent the accumulation of scale and sediment. This helps to prolong the lifespan of the water heater and maintain its efficiency. If you live in an area with hard water, it is recommended to look for water heater elements specifically labeled as “hard water resistant” or “scale resistant” to ensure optimal performance and longevity.

Can professional installation help optimize the performance of a water heater element in hard water conditions?

Yes, professional installation can certainly help optimize the performance of a water heater element, especially in hard water conditions. Hard water contains high levels of minerals like calcium and magnesium, which can cause scale buildup on the heating element over time. This scale buildup reduces the efficiency of the water heater, making it less effective at heating the water.

A professional installer will have the knowledge and experience to properly address the challenges posed by hard water conditions. They can recommend and install water treatment systems, such as water softeners or descaling devices, to minimize scale buildup in the water heater. By doing so, the heating element can operate more efficiently, leading to better overall performance and potentially extending its lifespan.

Additionally, a professional installer will ensure that the water heater is installed correctly, which is crucial for optimal performance. They will ensure proper electrical connections, insulation, and temperature settings, all of which can affect the efficiency and longevity of the heating element.

So, in summary, professional installation can indeed help optimize the performance of a water heater element in hard water conditions. It ensures that the water heater is installed correctly and may include measures to address the challenges posed by hard water, resulting in improved efficiency and longer-lasting performance.

Steve Donaldson Master HVAC technician
Steve DonaldsonMaster HVAC technician at Quality Comfort Home Services

I am Steve Donaldson, a Master HVAC technician with a rich background in addressing heating issues, especially when it comes to various types of water heaters. Leveraging my extensive expertise, I offer insights and advice to help individuals maintain a warm and secure home environment. Reach out to me at steve.donaldson@tedreviews.com for valuable tips from a seasoned professional in the industry.

More Posts

16 Comments
Show all Most Helpful Highest Rating Lowest Rating Add your review
  1. I’m looking for a budget-friendly option. Any recommendations for a water heater element that offers good value for money?

    • If you’re looking for a budget-friendly option, I would recommend considering the Camco Water Heater Element – 1500W, 120V. It offers good performance and durability at an affordable price. Let me know if you have any other questions!

  2. Can you provide more details on the EWH-05 Electric Water Heater Tune-Up Kit? What does it include and how does it help in maintaining water heater elements?

    • The EWH-05 Electric Water Heater Tune-Up Kit includes various components such as heating elements, a thermostat, and other necessary parts for tune-up or repair of electric water heaters. It helps in maintaining water heater elements by providing all the essential elements required for maintenance and ensuring optimal performance. Let me know if you need more information!

  3. Based on your expertise, could you recommend the best water heater element for extremely hard water? Thanks!

    • For extremely hard water, I would recommend considering the DERNORD 240V 4500W Screw-in Water Heater Element. It is specifically designed to withstand the challenges posed by hard water and provides excellent performance and longevity. Give it a try and let me know how it works for you!

  4. I’m a bit confused about the ‘universal flange’ feature. Can you expand on how the Reliance 4,500W Universal Flange Water Heater Element works and what it offers?

    • The ‘universal flange’ feature in the Reliance 4,500W Universal Flange Water Heater Element refers to its compatibility with different types of water heaters. It is designed to fit most standard water heaters with a flange mounting system. This ensures easy installation and compatibility with various models. Let me know if you have any other questions!

  5. Great roundup! Are there any plans to update this article with newer models or any other recommendations in the future?

    • Thank you! We always strive to keep our articles up to date. We regularly review and update our product roundups to include newer models and recommendations. Stay tuned for any updates!

  6. I’ve been using the Rheem UV12899 Heating Element for a while now and it has been working great. Any other similar models you would recommend?

    • Glad to hear that you’ve had a positive experience with the Rheem UV12899 Heating Element! If you’re looking for similar models, you might want to consider the DERNORD 240V 4500W Screw-in Water Heater Element or the Reliance 4,500W Universal Flange Water Heater Element. They offer similar performance and durability. Hope this helps!

  7. I’m not convinced that higher-priced options are always better. Has anyone tried the Eastman 60058 Water Heater Element? Is it worth the investment?

    • You’re right, higher-priced options may not always be better. The Eastman 60058 Water Heater Element is definitely worth considering if you’re looking for a reliable and cost-effective option. It offers good performance and durability without breaking the bank. Give it a try!

  8. Hi there! Maintaining water heater elements in hard water areas can be challenging. One tip is to regularly flush your water heater to remove mineral deposits. You can also consider using a water softener or installing a water treatment system. Hope this helps!

  9. I’ve been struggling with hard water issues for a while now. Does anyone have any tips on how to maintain water heater elements in hard water areas? Thanks!

Leave a reply

Tedreviews.com
Logo